Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peter Nayland Kust's avatar

What makes a book influential? That is a loaded question!

In the case of "Conagher", it was the sheer ordinariness of the main character. He wasn't anybody special, didn't have a superpower of any kind. He was just a man, with a code of ethics by which he lived, and he ended up having quite an impact on people just by being that man and living by that code.

I've found that to be a pretty powerful thought, the idea that we don't have to be supermen to make a difference, just men.

For me, the magic of a book (or any writing) is whether or not there's a thought that hangs around after I'm done. It might not even be the main thought in the book. It could be something offhand like Tyrion Lannister's advice to Jon Snow "wear who you are like armor".

If my own writing leaves people with some nugget of thought to chew on later, then I'm amply rewarded.

Expand full comment
Bowen Dwelle's avatar

As I memoirist, I read mostly memoir. Here's a discussion of nearly 50 of the books that made me:

https://bowendwelle.substack.com/p/43-favorite-memoirs-youve-never-heard

My top five

1) The Long Way by Bernard Moitessier -- one of the first real adventure memoirs, and a memoir of a truly unique feat of solo ocean sailing, a life lived outside, and outside and beyond the norm. Moitessier could have won the 1968 Golden Globe race—and along the way he invented a new way to sail the roaring forties—but instead of finishing he chose to sail on, to a new life.

2) Siberian Education, by Nicolai Lilin -- another memoir that showed me that memoir doesn't have to be all true. Lilin called it memoir at first, but then realized that it made more sense to call it something like auto-fiction, a term he hadn't been familiar with when writing. Entirely true or not, it's a brilliant chronicle of life outside the law in Siberia, and the source of several pearls of wisdom that I call upon often.

3) Sexus, by Henry Miller -- another work of autobiographical semi-fiction that broke all boundaries, that was banned and celebrated simultaneously, and that showed me personally that it would be possible to write how I wanted to write. Not that I write like Miller, but he showed me the way.

4) I Wrote This Book Because I Love You: Essays by Tim Kreider -- the book of memoir, in the form of autobiographical essays about ex girlfriends, that I was about to write, but didn't have to, because Tim did. Brilliant.

5) Practical Jung: Nuts and Bolts of Jungian Psychotherapy by Harry A. Wilmer -- the book that cracked Jungian psychology open for me, and, along with that, much of the lens through which I see the world.

Expand full comment
93 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?